The Pros And Cons Of Self-Insured Workers Compensation Insurance

Clients Consulting an Accountant

Workers compensation insurance is a crucial safety net for employees in case of injuries or illnesses caused by their job. It’s a requirement for employers in most states, and failing to carry it can lead to fines, lawsuits, and financial ruin.

While traditional workers compensation insurance policies are purchased through insurance carriers, some employers may choose to self-insure. Self-insured workers compensation insurance requires the employer to pay for any workers compensation claims out of pocket. This can be a risky gamble, but it also has its benefits.

In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of self-insured workers compensation insurance to help employers make an informed decision.

The Pros Of Self-Insured Workers Compensation Insurance

Cost Savings

One of the primary benefits of self-insured workers compensation insurance is the potential cost savings. Insurance companies charge premiums that include administrative costs, profits, and reserves for future claims. When an employer self-insures, they’re eliminating those costs and only paying for claims as they arise.

Self-insured employers who effectively manage their claims experience significant cost savings, leading to a lower overall cost of workers compensation insurance. Additionally, when claims are managed efficiently and costs are reduced, employers may be eligible for premium refunds or dividends.

Control Over Claims Management

When an employer purchases a traditional workers compensation insurance policy, the insurance carrier manages claims on the employer’s behalf. This means the insurance company controls the cost and severity of claims, which can impact the employer’s premium rates.

Self-insured employers have more control over their claims management. They can implement proactive safety programs, investigate accidents, and oversee medical treatment and rehabilitation to manage their costs and ensure their employees receive appropriate care.

Tailored Coverage

Insurance companies offer workers compensation policies with specific terms and conditions that may not meet an employer’s unique needs. Self-insured employers have the flexibility to tailor their workers compensation coverage to fit their business operations, workforce, and budget.

For example, employers may choose to exclude certain employees or types of injuries from their coverage, or they may provide additional benefits beyond what’s required by law. Employers can also negotiate better prices for medical treatment and rehabilitation services when managing claims themselves.

The Cons Of Self-Insured Workers Compensation Insurance

Financial Risk

The most significant disadvantage of self-insured workers compensation insurance is the potential for financial risk. Without the backing of an insurance carrier, employers must pay claims out of pocket, which can be a burden if costly claims arise. Employers must maintain adequate reserves to cover potential claims and meet state requirements for self-insurance.

Additionally, if an employer underestimates their potential risks and fails to set aside enough funds, they could face financial ruin or bankruptcy if a significant claim arises.

Administrative Burden

Self-insured employers take on significant administrative responsibilities that insurance carriers typically handle. Employers must develop and implement safety programs, manage claims, and ensure compliance with state laws and regulations. These tasks require time, resources, and expertise that may not be available in-house.

Outsourcing some or all of these responsibilities to third-party administrators or consultants can help alleviate the administrative burden, but those services come at a cost.

Workers compensation claims can lead to legal challenges, such as disputes over claim denials or benefit amounts. Self-insured employers must be prepared to handle these legal challenges, which can be costly and time-consuming.

Employers that lack the resources and experience to handle these disputes may end up paying more than necessary or damaging their reputation.

Conclusion

Self-insured workers compensation insurance is a significant decision for employers, and it requires careful consideration of the potential benefits and drawbacks. While self-insurance can lead to cost savings, greater control, and tailored coverage, the financial risk, administrative burden, and legal challenges must be accounted for.

Employers considering self-insured workers compensation insurance should consult with their legal and financial advisors to determine their potential risks and assess whether self-insurance is the right choice for their business.

Scroll to Top